top of page

The Person We Write Into the Record: Why ethical documentation deserves a place in the clinical conversation

Nov 15
5 min read
The Person We Write Into the Record: Why ethical documentation deserves a place in the clinical conversation
The Person We Write Into the Record: Why ethical documentation deserves a place in the clinical conversation

Somewhere between the end of a session and the next appointment, a person becomes a paragraph. An hour of conversation is condensed into a few lines that may be read months later by somebody who has never met them. We select what matters, decide how to describe it and leave out the rest. There is professional judgement in that process, even when we are simply trying to finish our notes before lunch.


Case notes rarely feature in the inspirational account of why somebody became a therapist. Yet they carry part of our care beyond the conversation itself. They help us remember what we understood, explain decisions and communicate with others involved in the work. They also preserve a particular account of the client, which makes the language we use worth examining.


A description can become a judgement


Consider an imagined session in which a client declines a suggested between-session exercise because it feels overwhelming alongside their caring responsibilities. A note that says “client was resistant” gives the next reader a very different starting point from one that records the client’s explanation and the agreement to revisit the plan. The second account preserves information about what happened and what was decided. It leaves the reader with something more useful than a label.


There is research showing why this deserves attention. In a 2018 randomised vignette study, Goddu and colleagues asked medical students and residents to read records describing the same hypothetical patient with sickle cell disease. Participants who read stigmatising language reported more negative attitudes towards the patient; residents also recommended less intensive pain treatment. This was a simulated medical scenario at one academic centre, so it cannot tell us precisely what happens in everyday counselling practice. It does, however, suggest a mechanism through which a record can carry bias from one practitioner to another.


For helping professionals, that invites a useful pause before turning an encounter into a character description. Words such as “difficult”, “attention-seeking” or “non-compliant” can obscure the behaviour we observed and the circumstances around it. Clinical interpretation has a legitimate place in a record, but its basis should be visible. A reader needs to understand how we reached the interpretation and how certain we are about it.


Enough detail to preserve the reasoning


The amount of detail creates another judgement call. A lengthy account can still leave a reader uncertain about why a particular decision was made. A brief note can communicate the essential information clearly, provided it preserves the context needed to understand it. Deciding what belongs depends on the purpose of the record, the circumstances of the work and the requirements that apply to the practitioner.


The Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care connects effective documentation with safe decision-making and continuity of care. Its guidance includes the person’s goals and preferences alongside assessments, risks and care priorities. That is a useful reminder that a record can help the next practitioner understand what the person is trying to achieve, as well as what concerns have been identified.


Australian privacy guidance also offers a helpful distinction between a judgement and a fact. The OAIC’s guidance on information quality explains that an opinion is not inaccurate merely because someone disagrees with it. Relevant considerations include whether it is recorded as an opinion, reflects the view actually held and is an informed assessment that considers competing information. In practice, that encourages us to distinguish what the client reported, what we observed and how we understood it.


That distinction leaves room for uncertainty. We can document that something remains unclear and explain the next step taken to understand it. We can also record when new information changes our assessment. A useful record allows the clinical thinking to develop as our understanding of the person develops.


The person may read the record


Thinking about future readers should include the person being described. For providers covered by the Privacy Act, the OAIC’s health privacy guidance recognises a general right to access health information held about a person, subject to exceptions. It specifically notes that apprehension or embarrassment about a patient reading the notes is not a legitimate reason to refuse access.


Writing with that possibility in mind asks something useful of us. A client may disagree with an assessment, or find parts of it uncomfortable, while still being able to recognise the events described and understand the reasoning. Serious concerns and difficult decisions need to be recorded clearly. Respectful language helps us explain those concerns without adding unnecessary judgement about the person.


This can also reveal what is missing. If the record contains our concerns but little of the client’s explanation, preferences or response, a future reader may inherit a very partial account. Making their perspective visible does not require agreement with everything they say. It helps preserve the context in which the work took place.


Quicker notes still need thoughtful authorship


Electronic templates and AI-assisted tools bring these questions into sharper focus. A template can prompt us to include information we might otherwise overlook, while also making a previous entry easy to carry forward without sufficient review. An AI-generated draft can be fluent and still require careful checking of what was included, omitted or interpreted. The finished record needs to reflect the encounter and the practitioner’s considered judgement.


The OAIC’s guidance on commercially available AI products emphasises privacy, suitability, data access and human oversight. It also recommends, as best practice, avoiding the entry of personal, and particularly sensitive, information into publicly available generative AI tools. For clinical documentation, decisions about efficiency therefore sit alongside decisions about where information goes and who can access it.


There is a practical workload question here as well. A practice that leaves record keeping to the exhausted minutes after a full day gives careful authorship very little support. Protected time, workable systems and opportunities to review documentation in supervision can help make the task more manageable. Professional responsibility becomes easier to exercise when the working arrangements make room for it.


One useful supervision exercise is to review a recent note using appropriate confidentiality safeguards. Consider whether another practitioner could understand the decisions from what is written, and whether the person described would recognise a fair account of the encounter. Those perspectives can reveal different gaps. A strong record helps the work remain understandable while allowing the client to remain a person whose circumstances and capacity for change extend beyond any single session.


Nexus College shares reflective articles and professional learning opportunities for practitioners who want to examine questions like these. Our colleagues at PESI offer Ethical Documentation in Behavioral Health with Frederic G. Reamer, PhD. You can also explore our learning calendar for further opportunities to develop your practice.




Comments


 Nexus College 


Established in 2007, by partnering with a number of providers around the globe Nexus College has grown to be the premier professional development network in the Asia Pacific Region.

 

Our company tag is ‘Study with friends!’ because that is the environment we like to create in all of our courses…

 

A fun, fast and fantastic learning environment!

 FOLLOW THE ARTIFACT: 
  • Facebook B&W
  • Twitter B&W
  • Instagram B&W
  • YouTube
 RECENT POSTS: 

© 2016 by Shane Warren & Associates

p. +61 (0)458 013 364 | info@nexuscollege.com.au | PO Box 1295 Darlinghurst NSW 2010 Aust.

  • Nexus College Australasia
  • Nexus College Australasia
  • Shane Warren Coaching & Counselling Services
  • Nexus College Australasia

Shane Warren & Associates recongises the traditional custodians of all the lands on which we meet...

Shane Warren: Coach, Counsellor, Consultant

We acknowledge the original peoples' connection to the land, sea, and air upon which we are invited to work...

bottom of page