When the Consulting Room Has Two Addresses: What competent online therapy asks of us

Imagine a client pausing halfway through a sentence, glancing towards a door and saying, “It’s fine. Carry on.” Through the screen, we can see the face and hear the reassurance. We have much less information about what prompted the interruption. Someone might be passing through the hallway, an uncomfortable conversation might be taking place nearby, or the courier might have arrived with another parcel nobody remembers ordering. The important thing is that we do not yet know.
That small moment captures something substantial about online therapy. We are working across two environments, each with its own possibilities and constraints. For clients managing distance, disability, caring responsibilities or limited local services, that arrangement can make an appointment more accessible. It also asks us to reconsider parts of practice that a shared consulting room once helped us organise almost without thinking.
The relationship can travel
There is good reason to take the relational possibilities of online work seriously. A systematic review and meta-analysis by Seuling and colleagues, published online in 2023 and in a 2024 journal issue, examined 18 publications comparing therapeutic alliance in videoconferencing and in-person psychotherapy. It found no statistically significant difference in alliance ratings from either clients or therapists. That is an encouraging finding about the possibility of meaningful therapeutic connection across a screen.
Its limits matter, too. An average finding about alliance does not establish that every client, intervention or setting is equally suited to online delivery. A useful implication for practice is that we can approach telehealth with confidence in its relational potential while remaining curious about the particular relationship in front of us. The screen allows contact; how we establish understanding, negotiate the work and notice difficulties still requires attention.
Privacy belongs to both rooms
That attention begins with the conditions in which someone can speak. A closed door at our end offers little information about the client’s surroundings. A person may have headphones on while their own voice remains audible through a thin wall. They may be comfortable discussing work stress at home but much less comfortable discussing the relationship with the person sitting in the next room. Privacy can change during a session, even when the internet connection remains admirably consistent.
We can explore those conditions collaboratively, without assuming everybody has a spare room and a cooperative household. A parked car may be someone’s most private available space; a shared home may require careful timing or another arrangement. Inviting the client to describe what feels possible gives us information that a simple “Are you somewhere private?” can miss. It also communicates that difficulties with the environment can be discussed, rather than concealed to keep the appointment going.
There is a separate responsibility for the information moving between those environments. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner’s health privacy guidance explicitly includes online counselling among the private health services covered by the Privacy Act. Platform choice, access to records and the handling of sensitive information therefore belong within our professional thinking. The privacy a client experiences and the protection their information receives are connected responsibilities, and both deserve more attention than a reassuring padlock symbol.
Distance changes the contingency plan
Once we acknowledge two environments, preparation for difficulties becomes more concrete. Knowing a client’s usual address is different from knowing where they are attending today’s appointment. A familiar face can join from another town, a relative’s house or somewhere they have never mentioned before. If significant distress emerges or the connection drops at a difficult moment, that context can become immediately important.
The Australian Psychological Society’s guidance for telehealth providers recommends advance contingency planning, including confirming the client’s location at each session, identifying appropriate local supports and agreeing what will happen if communication fails. Explaining these arrangements gives the client a clearer understanding of the service and its limits. Done thoughtfully, preparation can support trust: we have considered how to remain responsible when the session becomes more complicated than expected.
Presence needs a little translation
Preparation also creates room to pay better attention during the conversation itself. In a shared room, we may notice changes in posture, movement or breathing beyond the person’s face. On screen, the available information is framed differently, and delays can make the timing of an exchange uncertain. Silence might reflect thought, hesitation, distraction or a connection problem. Our interpretations benefit from being checked with the person experiencing it.
Sometimes that means making our own behaviour more explicit. Briefly explaining that we are looking down to take a note can prevent the client from having to guess where our attention has gone. Checking how a pause felt can open a useful conversation about connection. These are small adjustments, but they recognise that professional presence is something the client experiences through the conditions available to them.
The same clarity helps with boundaries beyond the appointment. A client who can enter therapy through a familiar device may also encounter reminders, messages and notifications through it. Agreements about contact between sessions, response times and the purpose of different communication channels help make the relationship understandable. The arrangements should be clear enough that neither person has to infer availability from the fact that a message could be sent.
Familiarity is a starting point for competence
Many practitioners now have considerable experience of online work. That familiarity is useful, and it can also make routines harder to examine. An established consent process, a comfortable platform or a session format that usually works can begin to feel settled. Reviewing practice means remaining willing to ask how those arrangements serve this client, under these circumstances, and whether something has changed.
For practitioners regulated by AHPRA and the National Boards, current telehealth guidance maintains the expectations of professional care and emphasises competence, suitability and ongoing assessment of whether remote delivery is appropriate. Across the wider helping professions, practitioners also need to work with their own association’s standards and scope of practice. International learning can sharpen our thinking, provided we translate it carefully: US frameworks such as HIPAA and HITECH address a different legal setting from Australian privacy and professional requirements.
A useful place to continue that examination is supervision. Bringing an online session into supervision allows us to consider the conditions around the conversation alongside its content: what we could observe, what we checked, what we assumed and how we responded to uncertainty. We might return to the client glancing towards the door and consider how we would explore that moment. What would help this person tell us what is happening at their end—and what might our usual way of beginning a session leave unspoken?
Nexus College shares reflective articles and professional learning opportunities for practitioners who want to examine questions like these. Our colleagues at PESI offer the 2-Day Certified Clinical Telemental Health Provider Training with Melissa Westendorf, PhD, JD, exploring ethical, legal and technological aspects of remote practice. You can also browse our learning calendar for further opportunities to develop your practice.


Comments